You guys are great! 7 points for not mentioning Super Glue or duct tape.
Seriously, I tried to 're-surface' a timer's contacts once with one a conductive silver 'plating' pen (after filing and polishing), I found that the 'spring' of the contact arms had weakened (with heat, from the original failure) so just 're-plating' the surface didn't work after a week (new contact rivet? never tried that!)